9600GT or 3870

Discussion in 'Graphics Cards & Displays' started by PowerSlide, Feb 29, 2008.

  1. Mac Daddy

    Mac Daddy Pickin' Da Gitfiddle

    What are you using for RAM ?
     
  2. DarKSeeD

    DarKSeeD BOG Translator

    Here are my scores with a Forsa 9600GT, Asus 3870 and Asus 3870 TOP with Glaciator cooling.
    Testbed:
    Asus P5B Deluxe - Bios 1226
    Intel Q6600 Stock
    4GB DDR2 - Kingston@667
    2xSamsung Spinpoint 320GB
    XP Pro 32bit + SP2
    3Dmark 06 Professional 1.1.0

    174.74 geforce drivers
    8.3 Catalyst drivers

    Results:
    9600GT - 1280x1024x32 = 10596 points (default driver settings)
    - 1280x1024x32 = 9512 points (High Quality)
    - 1024x768x32 = 11451 points (default driver settings)
    - 1024x768x32 = 10691 points (High Quality)


    Asus 3870 Top - 1280x1024x32 = 11195 points (default driver settings)
    - 1280x1024x32 = 9410 points (High Quality)

    Asus 3870 - 1280x1024x32 = 10885 points (default driver settings)
    - 1024x768x32 = 11773 points (default driver settings)

    Both 3870 have Glaciator cooling, much better cooling than the reference one. Also the cards were pretty silent! Not the same thing I can say about the 9600GT which was pretty loud under full load.
    I can say without any doubt that the price will make the difference.
     
  3. Lacus

    Lacus Newbie

    my rams? 4x1GB Corsair Value ram. Frame rate is ok..Typo earlier..Just the marks are pretty low for some reason =/
     
  4. Mac Daddy

    Mac Daddy Pickin' Da Gitfiddle

    OK wasn't sure if you might be running less than 4G I am sure thats the reason X64 is running faster than XP for me at the moment :)
     
  5. Exilon

    Exilon Newbie

    What I can see from 9600gt benchmarks around the web is that the 9 series have superior performance when anti aliasing is turned on compared to HD3780 without AA. Do you have any trials with AF?
     
  6. DarKSeeD

    DarKSeeD BOG Translator

    When I stated HQ, well, I was using 16xAF in all the tests but AA was left on Application-controlled. To be honest I don't care too much about AA as playing on higher resolutions usually provides a better image quality.
     
  7. CALLOFDUTY05

    CALLOFDUTY05 Newbie

    2GB (1 stick) Transcend DDR2-800. :roll:
     
    Last edited: Apr 18, 2008
  8. Mac Daddy

    Mac Daddy Pickin' Da Gitfiddle

    Whoopsie it was you I asked Lacus responded lol .. its old age on my part :mrgreen:

    Anyhew Bro as I said in the previous quote if your not using 4G+ RAM then your not going to see a huge difference between XP and Vista X64.
     
  9. gen_inthera

    gen_inthera Newbie

    Hi All TechARP members,
    I would like to buy nvidia 9600GT, I think this is a nice card for my PC. My system spec as follow:
    AMD 64 X2 4400+
    KINGSTONS DD2 PC-5300 2 X 1 GB
    BIOSTAR TA690G MOTHERBOARD
    PIONER DVD-RW SATA
    250GB SATA HARDDRIVE SEAGATE
    PSU 400W POWER LOGIC

    I am need your recomendation, does my PSU need to be upgraded ? if yes, could you mention which PSU best to my system and what brand for 9600GT card ?

    Thank's all
     
  10. Lacus

    Lacus Newbie

    Well, should be more than enough :) LOL, I got myself confused too...haha... :lol: Now was thinking should i go Vista X64 =/ Drivers should be kinda hard to get eh?
     
  11. Mac Daddy

    Mac Daddy Pickin' Da Gitfiddle

    Actually the NV Vista 64 bit driver is working quite well here no issues so far and haven't had issues with anything else so far. Just watch older hardware with Vista :)
     
  12. Chai

    Chai Administrator Staff Member

    My system works extremely well with 64bit driver wise. Program compatibility is an issue though.
     
  13. akakiller07

    akakiller07 Newbie

    hmm, i would prefer 9600GT
     
  14. Mac Daddy

    Mac Daddy Pickin' Da Gitfiddle

    Still kind of new to Vista Chai and haven't really had a chance to install many games or programs aside from the ones I use regularly yet. Are there any particular programs or hardware drivers you have had issues with really curious to know just for knowledge sake :)
     
  15. Chai

    Chai Administrator Staff Member

    Hardware issue, no, other than EMU0404 drivers which crashes when I remote desktop. I'm very new to Vista and 64bit too. :mrgreen:

    Many old software don't work, Partition Magic, Nero 6, Dreamweaver MX, no 64bit Nikon RAW plugin. I haven't installed games yet.
     
  16. Digerati

    Digerati Newbie

    Not really sure. 400W would be enough (I think), but I'm not sure if Power Logic PSU's are reliable. It's best if you upgrade it for the card and future usage.
     
  17. Adrian Wong

    Adrian Wong Da Boss Staff Member

    Hmm.. I thought Partition Magic and Nero 6 wouldn't work with Vista-32 either? :think:

    I'm using updated versions of Nero and Dreamweaver, albeit with Vista 32.
     
  18. Lacus

    Lacus Newbie

    400w should be more than enough. But if i'm not mistaken, power logic psu are not true power. it depends though. I myself might might 3870(coz 10.1) over 9600gt (10.0) for future usage. 9600gt is a midrange card so i think it does not need higher power?
     

Share This Page