P2P traffic clogging broadband (from tmnet)

Discussion in 'Internet & Networking' started by ALstonLoong, Mar 5, 2006.

  1. ALstonLoong

    ALstonLoong Newbie

    Just read this from thestar

    http://star-techcentral.com/tech/story.asp?file=/2006/3/1/technology/13540730&sec=technology

    humm ...i thought adsl is individual line that wont affect other user ?:doh:
     
    Last edited by a moderator: Mar 5, 2006
  2. Papercut

    Papercut Newbie

    What's the big deal? It's not like you need all that bandwidth for "mere" web surfing and chatting :roll:
     
  3. Chai

    Chai Administrator Staff Member

    20% of the users choking up 80% of the bandwidth? Isn't that a sign of them NEEDING TO UPGRADE??? :wall:
     
  4. ALstonLoong

    ALstonLoong Newbie

    yeah..to me is more like they needed to upgrade their server .. instead of blaming p2p choking up local broadband lines. If i remember correctly ... adsl is not like cable which every user share the same optic cable. Adsl user have their own line and wont affect other user even u download tons of stuff.

    so wat he said is not making any sense to me....:doh:
     
  5. Chai

    Chai Administrator Staff Member

    Not really. If the submarine cable can only cope 1Gbps (example), you can only fit that much bandwidth thru that.

    Yes everyone has their own line, but all the line still have to go thru that bottleneck.
     
  6. ZuePhok

    ZuePhok Just Started

    if you want to offer the service, u do it right.

    otherwise, _|_

    stop blaming ur customer. you monopoly the market and you have been offering very bad services all this while...and now you say shit like this to us? _|_

    what do u mean by minority? we are ur customer u dxxb a88.
     
  7. ALstonLoong

    ALstonLoong Newbie

    yup i understand:haha: .

    What im trying to say is, since everyone have their own line, doesnt that means tmnet suppose to provide that amount of bandwidth to user since we paid for it..? We didnt abuse our bandwidth... we have the right to use wat ever bandwidth we paid for isnt it( for example 1M adsl) ? tmnet server got choked thats because they need to upgrade their server they should not put the blame on user for abusing it ,isnt it?cause adsl is not like cable... we just use wat we paid for the line. Is a private line ..not shared.

    just my 2 cents :shifty:
     
  8. Falcone

    Falcone Official Mascot Creator

    not really. Broadband is shared service That's why it's so cheap. Lease line is dedicated.
     
  9. Dashken

    Dashken Administrator!

    Well, Malaysian's agencies tend to put blame on the consumers or anything that they can get on rather than their inefficiency. Look at Streamyx, so many promotions, free this and free that, when have you heard of them upgrading this and that? They only want more money, but when they can't cope with the increase usage, they blame us. KNN! Stupid people! :evil:
     
  10. AAY

    AAY ARP Reviewer

    It doesn't work that way. Say you run an ISP with 10,000 users and you each of them buys 1.0/512 ADSL service from you. Would you then go out and get a 10Gbit line? There really is no reason to - it is highly unlikely that at any one instant all your users will be downloading large files from foreign servers. So the ISP must calculate what it believes its peak usage will be and get whatever lines it needs then.
     
  11. Adrian Wong

    Adrian Wong Da Boss Staff Member

    Agreed. But I don't think they should punish users for maxxing out their lines.

    After all, if you are paying for 1mbps, you have the right to use all 1mbps.

    Of course, if we all start maxxing out our lines, they will probably be forced to upgrade their bandwidth and increase their prices. :think:
     

Share This Page